Is UDL Just Another “Fad” In Education?


The other day, I overheard someone say, “Here is another new thing they want us to try.”  This is not something new, I have heard this comment made many a time during staff meetings and PD days.  It made me think is Universal Design for Learning (UDL) just another new thing that we are making people do?  Will our practice really change?
Last week my grandfather passed away.  While my aunt and mother were going through to clean out his room, they came across a book on my grandfather’s bookshelf titled, “Learning to Speak and Write”.  It was published in 1924.  When I opened it and read the foreword to teachers, I was shocked and disgusted.


“The above-average mind is the most valuable single asset of the race”

This statement made me realize that, although it seems that we go back and forth or seemingly in cycles in education, we are making progress.  In 1924, it was acceptable to value the above-average mind as our single most valuable asset and I have no doubt that this above-average mind was judged based on their reading, writing and math skills.

Currently, we are focused on building community and respecting diversity in our division.  We are teaching our students that people learn differently and that we all have different smarts or intelligence.  No longer do we believe that those, who are strong readers, writers, and are good with numbers are the smartest people in the room.  People are smart in many different ways.  We talk about word smart and how it can be applied in various ways: number smart, picture smart, body smart, nature smart, music smart, people smart and myself smart, all equally valuable.

This is a relief to me, as growing up, I never felt like I was “smart”.  I was the kid that was pulled from class to go to the reading resource room.  I have never been a strong writer, in fact this is my first blog post. I have been building up the courage to write for the past 5 months.  Number smart would also not describe me.  Strange that I wanted to be a teacher, even though I was never a strong student.

Through UDL, we are headed towards  true inclusion. Jennifer Katz explained it well at a session she did at the Edmonton Regional Learning Consortium. She discussed how that in many schools we are still in the parallel play phase.  We have many students, who in the past were excluded by being taught in separate schools or classrooms are now in our classrooms being taught parallel to most students. However, they are being taken out of their class into small groups or working on other things even in the same room with their Educational Assistant.  That is not inclusion!  Inclusion means every student at the table. It means all students get the same task but could have different goals. While, we are not there yet, we are moving in that direction.

Education has come a long way since 1924.  It  is important to think about our practice and consider why and how we are doing things.  Focusing on UDL has made me question the way I have done things in my class.  Do my students feel safe, cared about, and loved?  Are ALL my students at the table?  What barriers are there for my students?  How can they best show what they know?

Does this take time? Yes it does, but it is important work that we are doing. UDL is not a fad, it is just a part of our journey to true inclusion!


3 thoughts on “Is UDL Just Another “Fad” In Education?

  1. I’m watching Colin be included in ways that I never thought possible! It’s because of their teachers that are willing to take risks and put in the “front end loading” time! It is often messy and not always perfect…but the moment when a student is trying to figure out which word will best describe a WHMIS symbol to a non-verbal student who uses an AAC device….that’s when you know you are achieving UDL!!!!


    1. He has also been fortunate to have amazing EA’s working with his teachers. They play a huge role that is often over looked. I know when I worked with Lynelle she was great with giving me ideas, even on the fly of how we could include Colin as much as possible. EA’s have a different view of our classroom. They see things that we miss or did not think about.

      I love that you are sharing Colin’s journey through videos. It shows people what is possible. Sharing your experience is so powerful and can help others think outside the box of possible ways they can work towards true inclusion in their classrooms. I am excited to be invited into Colleen’s science class next week. She is doing amazing things with amazing people like you!


    2. Change is always difficult and more often than not messy. I can’t agree with you more Christine, UDL is not a fad. It is a path to our future in education. It is time to change our traditional model of schooling. So glad we have professionals like you leading our way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s